Previous Message Return to Archive 2002 Next Message

Archive Number 988

Date: Tue, 8 Jan 2002 11:32:46 EST
From: Caren Neile
Subject: Re: Story and Transformation






"What do we mean anyway when we speak of "transformation" and
how is this accomplished through story?"

Dear Cristy, I think your question about transformation is one of the most
important that can be asked about storytelling, and I applaud you for raising
it. The legendary anthropologist Victor Turner identified the social drama
(human interaction) and, more specifically, ritual/performance, as very much
like the plot of a story: 1) breach (leaving home or the status quo, opening
oneself to new experience or knowledge), 2) crisis (a problem/question to be
addressed) 3) redress (addressing the crisis) and 4) reintegration or
schism, (either returning to the familiar with the knowledge gained through
this process or leaving it altogether for new frontiers). Turner identified
the transitional period between stages 2 and 4 as the "liminal stage" or
threshold between one state of being and another. This, he believed, is the
stage in which art takes place. We might also think of it as the larval
stage.

You can see how the four stages are closely associated with adolescent rites
of passage, such as a young man's first hunt or working toward the Bar
Mitzvah. When we tell or hear a story, we accompany the characters on this
journey through the four stages. We are in the liminal state while we are in
the midst of it, and, if the story "works" for us, we emerge transformed,
like a butterfly, at some point after it is over.

Incidentally, in Turner's analysis, the social drama led to the establishment
of communitas, or deep communal feeling. This is one reason I believe so
strongly in the power of story to resolve differences. (Ah ha! A plug for the
Social Action Committee!)

If this discussion interests you, see Turner's Anthropology of Performance
and The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-structure.)

I wish you all the best, always.

Caren